Rules and compliance
HIPAA and review replies
Also called: HIPAA review response, PHI in reviews
Under HIPAA, healthcare providers cannot disclose a patient's protected health information when replying to online reviews, even if the patient already shared details in the review. Confirming that the reviewer is a patient, naming them or mentioning their treatment can all count as a disclosure.
What it means in practice
The Office for Civil Rights at HHS has settled with dental practices over review replies. One Texas practice paid $10,000 in 2019 after disclosing patients' names and treatment details in replies on Yelp. A California practice paid $23,000 in 2022 for similar replies.
A safe reply thanks the reviewer for the feedback in general terms, does not confirm they were seen, and invites them to call the office directly.
Why it matters
One careless reply can mean a federal investigation, a settlement and a corrective action plan.
RepliedHQ's health rules never confirm someone is a patient and never mention treatment. Only five-star reviews post automatically; everything else comes to you first.